august-2025-book-reviews
Explanation
The Joke
This is one of Zach Weinersmith's periodic "Books of the Month" comics, where he recommends books he has recently read and enjoyed. This installment features three books:
-
Bloodlands: Europe Between Hitler and Stalin by Timothy Snyder — Described as "a beautiful, high-detailed account of the theaters of horrors that ran from Eastern Europe through Russia during the years between the rise of Nazism and the end of Stalinism."
-
The Face of Battle by John Keegan — Described as "an attempt to give the sights, sounds, smells, and feeling of actual combat by covering the famed battles of Agincourt, Waterloo, and the Somme."
-
Replaceable You by Mary Roach — Described as something to the effect that it is about the modern science of replaceable body parts, told with the author's usual combination of curiosity and hilarity.
The Format
Unlike typical SMBC strips, the book review comics are not joke-driven. They serve as genuine recommendations from Weinersmith, who is a voracious reader across history, science, philosophy, and social science. The format is straightforward: book cover images accompanied by brief, enthusiastic descriptions.
The Books
Bloodlands (2010) by Timothy Snyder is a landmark work of history that examines the region between Germany and Russia where the Nazi and Soviet regimes collectively murdered approximately 14 million people between 1933 and 1945. Rather than treating the Holocaust and Soviet atrocities separately, Snyder examines how these killing campaigns overlapped geographically and sometimes interacted with each other.
The Face of Battle (1976) by John Keegan is considered one of the most important works of military history ever written. Keegan broke from traditional military historiography, which focused on strategy and generalship, to instead examine what combat was actually like for the soldiers who fought. By comparing three battles spanning five centuries, Keegan showed how the experience of warfare changed dramatically over time.
Replaceable You by Mary Roach continues her tradition of accessible, humorous science writing (previously seen in books like Stiff, Bonk, and Gulp), this time examining the science of replacing human body parts.
Broader Context
Weinersmith's book recommendation comics reflect his wide-ranging intellectual interests and serve as a genuine public service to his readers. His audience skews toward scientifically literate, intellectually curious readers who appreciate these curated suggestions. The mix of a harrowing WWII history, a classic of military historiography, and a humorous popular science book is typical of the eclectic range Weinersmith covers.