Explain SMBC — the wiki for Saturday Morning Breakfast Cereal

calculating-2

2025-04-24 View on smbc-comics.com → 2 revisions
calculating-2
Votey panel for calculating-2
This explanation is incomplete or may contain errors. It was generated by AI and has not yet been reviewed by a human editor.

Explanation

This comic imagines a scenario in which our entire universe is actually an "agent-based model of the economy" -- a computer simulation built by some higher-dimensional researchers. The comic opens with a woman addressing a glowing, ovoid entity (presumably the simulation's interface or "God"), asking: "God, what are we calculating for you?" The entity responds with a confused "Huh?"

The woman presses the point: "Don't play coy. Nobody builds a universe this complex without trying to answer some question." This is a nod to the simulation hypothesis -- the philosophical idea, popularized by Nick Bostrom among others, that our reality might be an elaborate computer simulation run by a more advanced civilization. The comic takes this premise and gives it an absurdly mundane purpose.

It turns out the universe is not a full-scale simulation but merely a "proof of concept" -- an agent-based model of an economy. The researchers are "hoping to get funding to do a full size one," then immediately walk that back to "well, a medium size one. But maybe later full size." This mirrors the all-too-familiar pattern in academic grant proposals, where researchers oversell their ambitions and then hedge.

When the woman asks what scenario they are testing, the answer is: "Sexually reproducing species who lack telepathy but can use money." This is a hilariously reductive description of humanity -- stripping away everything we consider meaningful about human civilization and reducing us to a few bullet points on a simulation specification sheet.

The final punchline comes when the woman asks "Why?" this particular scenario, and the entity responds: "If we can get the funders to laugh, we are in." The entire premise of human existence -- sexual reproduction, lack of telepathy, reliance on money -- was chosen not for scientific rigor but because it would be funny enough to impress grant reviewers. This layers multiple jokes: the absurdity of our existence being a comedy pitch, the cynicism about how academic funding actually works (entertainment value over scientific merit), and the existential horror of learning that the defining features of your species were selected for their comedic value.

View History (2) Original Comic
← Previous Comic Next Comic →