Explain SMBC — the wiki for Saturday Morning Breakfast Cereal

i-object

2015-11-08 View on smbc-comics.com → 1 revision
You are viewing an older revision of this explanation (2026-03-14 21:07:07). View current version →
i-object
Votey panel for i-object
This explanation is incomplete or may contain errors. It was generated by AI and has not yet been reviewed by a human editor.

Explanation

The Joke

At a wedding, the officiant says the traditional line: "If anyone objects to this marriage, let them speak now." A statistician in the audience immediately interjects: "That's not a statistically sound approach to making objections!" She proceeds to argue that objection isn't binary -- it's a spectrum. She insists that everyone in the church probably has some level of objection between zero and a hundred, and that by forcing people to choose between yes-objection and non-objection, you're tilting things in favor of the marriage going forth. She argues they should really get a distribution of everyone's objections, then see how far they deviate from the typical marriage-objection distribution.

She eventually suggests: "If anyone's objection to this marriage is greater than one sigma, speak now!" The officiant concedes: "Very well. The marriage may proceed." Someone asks "Do we know you?" and she flies away wearing a cape, declaring "Rogue statistician awaayyyyyyy!"

The Humor

The comic satirizes the tendency of statistically-minded people to over-analyze everyday social conventions. The traditional wedding objection is a simple binary ritual (speak up or hold your peace), but the statistician treats it as a flawed survey methodology. Her complaints are technically valid from a statistical perspective -- binary yes/no questions do lose information compared to continuous scales, and selection bias could indeed affect who speaks up. But applying rigorous statistical methodology to a wedding ceremony is hilariously inappropriate. The "rogue statistician" superhero exit at the end elevates her from a mere pedant to a vigilante crusader for proper statistical methods.

The votey ("It's unlikely that you can stop me!") is a statistics pun, using the language of probability to make a threat, staying perfectly in character.

References

  • Standard deviation (sigma) is a measure of statistical dispersion. Being "one sigma" away from the mean indicates a value that falls outside the range containing roughly 68% of observations in a normal distribution.
  • The traditional wedding phrase "speak now or forever hold your peace" originated in medieval Christian wedding ceremonies and was historically a legal mechanism to surface impediments to marriage.
View History (1) Original Comic