Explain SMBC — the wiki for Saturday Morning Breakfast Cereal

Law

2021-02-16 View on smbc-comics.com → 1 revision
Law
Votey panel for Law
This explanation is incomplete or may contain errors. It was generated by AI and has not yet been reviewed by a human editor.

Explanation

The Joke

Two people are having a conversation. One asks: "God, if you did something evil, wouldn't it be ethical to arrest you?" The response is: "Absolutely." The first person follows up: "Would it be ethical to arrest bigtime criminals too?" The answer again: "Bigtime."

Then the second person explains: "What is the point of morals and law, then?" The first responds: "I am trying to sort regular people from people willing to follow the letter of a long set of complex, often self-contradictory rules." The final panel reveals the punchline: "I am assembling a legal team because I have done some bad stuff." The other person simply says: "Ugh."

The comic starts with what seems like a philosophical discussion about ethics and law, but reveals that the speaker is not making an intellectual argument at all -- they are recruiting. They want to find people who will follow complex contradictory rules (i.e., lawyers) precisely because they need legal representation for their own crimes.

The Humor

The humor comes from the bait-and-switch structure. The opening panels set up what appears to be a deep philosophical conversation about the nature of morality versus legality -- a classic SMBC topic. But the rug is pulled out when it turns out the entire Socratic dialogue was just a roundabout job interview for defense attorneys. The joke also functions as a commentary on lawyers and the legal profession, suggesting that the skill of navigating contradictory and complex rules is less about justice and more about helping guilty people escape consequences. The exasperated "Ugh" in the final panel perfectly captures the listener's frustration at having been dragged into a philosophical discussion under false pretenses.

References

The comic touches on longstanding debates in philosophy of law about the relationship between morality and legality, including legal positivism (the idea that law and morality are separate) and natural law theory (the idea that unjust laws are not truly laws). The joke also references the common stereotype of lawyers as people skilled at exploiting loopholes in complex rule systems.

View History (1) Original Comic
← Previous Comic Next Comic →