Explain SMBC — the wiki for Saturday Morning Breakfast Cereal

One Wish

2015-05-20 View on smbc-comics.com → 1 revision
One Wish
Votey panel for One Wish
This explanation is incomplete or may contain errors. It was generated by AI and has not yet been reviewed by a human editor.

Explanation

The Joke

A man is granted one wish by a genie and wishes to outlive all of his enemies. This creates a perverse incentive: since his enemies must stay alive for him to keep living, he now needs to make sure all his enemies are healthy. He starts being kind to them -- calling his enemy Bob to check in, telling his ex-wife she was right about everything, apologizing for stabbing someone in the neck, and apologizing for setting someone's house on fire. The kindness becomes reciprocal and they all become friends. But this creates a problem: now he has no enemies, so there is no guarantee of his continued survival. He desperately tries to make new enemies but fails -- he calls a baby a scumbag (the man just shrugs it off), tries to fight an old man (who just wants to be friends and watch cartoons), and even his earlier wave of kindness has spread into a global meme of forgiveness. Finally, he loses his sanity, screaming "There is no safety! There are no enemies!" His body outlives his mind, and the genie declares: "Your wish is technically granted."

The Humor

The comic is an elaborate exploration of a "monkey's paw"-style wish that backfires through an unexpected chain of logical consequences. The wish to outlive all enemies creates a survival incentive to be kind to enemies, which turns them into friends, which eliminates the very condition keeping him alive. The escalating absurdity -- from individual reconciliation to accidentally creating world peace to total psychological breakdown -- follows a rigorous internal logic while becoming increasingly ridiculous. The final punchline, "Your wish is technically granted," is the classic genie loophole: he does outlive all his enemies, but only because he has gone insane and his body persists in a state of madness, which is not at all what he intended.

References

  • The comic follows the "monkey's paw" trope, named after W.W. Jacobs' 1902 short story, in which wishes are granted in ironic and harmful ways that technically fulfill the letter of the wish but violate its spirit.
  • The genie wish gone wrong is a staple of folklore and fiction, often used to illustrate the dangers of poorly worded wishes.
View History (1) Original Comic
← Previous Comic Next Comic →