Explain SMBC — the wiki for Saturday Morning Breakfast Cereal

Paradise

2020-12-31 View on smbc-comics.com → 1 revision
Paradise
Votey panel for Paradise
This explanation is incomplete or may contain errors. It was generated by AI and has not yet been reviewed by a human editor.

Explanation

The Joke

Someone asks God whether heaven is real. God confirms it is, but then describes the enormous complexity of actually designing a paradise. First, you have to figure out what paradise even means -- and every version "sucks" because a world with no problems is essentially boring. Then there's the problem of billions of people with incompatible desires. God mentions that running a probability simulation involves considerations like "what about people who eat bats" leading to pandemics, whether ice ages can happen, and balancing all of humanity's conflicting wishes. The cherubs, God admits, "freaked me out" as a design choice, described with "50 eyes and tiny angel wings."

Then comes the real challenge: deciding whether, on balance, living in a multiverse is net positive. If it is, God would need to provide paradise for every being, including "every healthcare worker." The person listening says "Sounds stressful," and God replies: "It's hell up here" -- a pun on the fact that the difficulty of managing heaven makes heaven itself a kind of hell for God.

The Humor

The comic applies mundane project management and design thinking to the concept of creating an afterlife, treating God as an overwhelmed systems engineer rather than an omnipotent deity. The humor comes from the gap between the grand theological concept of paradise and the grubby reality of trying to actually design one that works. The "what about people who eat bats" line is a clear reference to COVID-19 pandemic origin theories, grounding the cosmic in the very contemporary. The final punchline -- "It's hell up here" -- works both as a literal inversion (heaven is hell for its administrator) and as a relatable joke about anyone who has ever had to manage a complex project with too many stakeholders.

References

The comic touches on the theological "problem of paradise" -- the difficulty of conceiving a coherent, desirable afterlife. This is related to but distinct from the problem of evil. The reference to biblical cherubs with many eyes alludes to their actual description in Ezekiel 10, where they are described as having four faces and being covered in eyes -- far from the chubby babies of Renaissance art. The "eating bats" line references the theory that COVID-19 originated from bat coronaviruses, likely through an intermediate host, placing this comic firmly in early 2021 pandemic context.

View History (1) Original Comic
← Previous Comic Next Comic →