Explain SMBC — the wiki for Saturday Morning Breakfast Cereal

prayer-6

2025-11-12 View on smbc-comics.com → 1 revision
prayer-6
Votey panel for prayer-6
This explanation is incomplete or may contain errors. It was generated by AI and has not yet been reviewed by a human editor.

Explanation

A person is praying: "Dear God, why don't you answer prayers?" God responds: "Sally, you have three coworkers you personally wished death on."

Sally protests: "Those were more like... things I would theoretically put in a prayer." God asks: "What if it works?" Sally has a moment of realization and says: "Dear God, would you... would you have deleted me first?" God responds: "But you see, murder is murder."

The comic explores the logical contradictions inherent in prayer, particularly prayers that wish harm on others. The joke begins with the classic theological question of why God doesn't answer prayers, but quickly pivots to reveal that the person asking has been praying for her coworkers to die. God's refusal to answer prayers is reframed not as divine indifference but as a practical safety measure -- if God actually fulfilled prayer requests, people like Sally (who casually wish death on annoying coworkers) would be wielding divine power irresponsibly.

The deeper joke emerges when Sally realizes the implication: if God answered all prayers, her coworkers might have prayed for her death too, meaning she might have been "deleted" first. This creates a kind of mutually assured destruction scenario through prayer, which neatly explains why a rational God might choose not to answer any prayers at all.

The comic satirizes the casual violence people express in everyday frustrations ("I could kill my coworker") by taking these sentiments literally in a theological context. It also offers a humorous theodicy (explanation for why God permits suffering/doesn't intervene): God's non-intervention isn't cruelty -- it's the only rational policy when humans would weaponize divine power against each other.

View History (1) Original Comic
← Previous Comic Next Comic →