Explain SMBC — the wiki for Saturday Morning Breakfast Cereal

the-market-for-bread

2016-08-05 View on smbc-comics.com → 1 revision
You are viewing an older revision of this explanation (2026-03-14 20:41:14). View current version →
the-market-for-bread
Votey panel for the-market-for-bread
This explanation is incomplete or may contain errors. It was generated by AI and has not yet been reviewed by a human editor.

Explanation

The Joke

The comic is set in a biblical or ancient marketplace. A bearded man (resembling Jesus) tells someone: "Sorry, kids. I had to close down the family fish market. There's a man selling fish in town whose prices are so low that I lose money on every sale." His children respond with their own ambitious dreams: "But I was going to get an education and become a philosopher!" and "I was going to run for office and change the world!"

In the final panel, the father says, "I know, kids. I know. We all had so many dreams," followed by a somber "I know." The comic presents the crushing of dreams and ambitions through the simple mechanism of market competition -- a cheaper competitor has destroyed the family business and, with it, the entire family's future aspirations.

The Humor

The comic applies modern economic concepts -- specifically market competition and price undercutting -- to a biblical-era setting to highlight how economic forces have always shaped and constrained human potential. The children's dreams of philosophy and political leadership are shown to be contingent on something as mundane as fish prices. The humor is dark and understated: grand ambitions are not destroyed by war, plague, or tyranny, but by basic supply-and-demand economics. It reads as both a commentary on how market forces can be indifferent to human flourishing and a gentle parody of how economics stories often ignore the human cost of "efficient markets."

References

The setting and character designs evoke the biblical era, and the fish market reference may allude to the prominence of fishing in the Gospels (several of Jesus's disciples were fishermen). The economic concept being explored is market competition and its effects on small businesses -- a topic extensively discussed since Adam Smith's "The Wealth of Nations" (1776). The comic can also be read as a commentary on modern issues like large corporations undercutting small businesses.

View History (1) Original Comic