Explain SMBC — the wiki for Saturday Morning Breakfast Cereal

best-2

2024-01-30 View on smbc-comics.com → 1 revision
best-2
Votey panel for best-2
This explanation is incomplete or may contain errors. It was generated by AI and has not yet been reviewed by a human editor.

Explanation

This comic parodies the concept of prayer as a competitive optimization problem.

A person prays: "Dear God, is this the best of all possible universes?" This is a reference to Leibniz's theodicy -- the philosophical argument that God, being omnipotent and benevolent, must have created the best of all possible worlds (famously satirized by Voltaire in "Candide").

God responds: "What's the biggest number related to 'is it my number? Is it higher?'" The person asks, "There are infinite possible universes, dumb dumb?" God fires back: "That's not the game." The person then suggests, "True, biggest would be at least countable, unless there's..." and God cuts them off: "You could've had the first comfortable online 'best,' said no."

The humor works on several levels. First, it treats the theological question about the best possible universe as though it's equivalent to the "guess the number" game -- both involve trying to identify one optimal value from an infinite set. God's frustration mirrors the logical impossibility: just as you can't guess "the biggest number" (because there isn't one), you can't meaningfully ask if something is "the best" when the comparison set is infinite. The reference to countable versus uncountable infinities adds a layer of mathematical humor -- the person starts getting into set theory (whether the set of possible universes is countably or uncountably infinite), which would indeed matter for whether "best" is even a coherent concept. The punchline suggests God offered an easy win and the person overthought it.

View History (1) Original Comic
← Previous Comic Next Comic →